Battle of the Benefit Mascara

We all know Benefit mascara’s are amazing, but do we know which one is the best? Which one completely out-does the others? Which one’s better for length, curl, volume? Well I’m here to let you know which one I think is the best.

Benefit Mascara

I’ve wrote out a quick explanation on what I think of all the mascaras, and I have scored them out for 10 for; lengthening, curl, blackness, volume, packaging & wand.

Benefit They're Real BADgal lash Roller Lash

This mascara is perfect if you’re wanting some serious volume and maybe not as much length. The wand is really densely packed and quite big in size, which is what I always look for in a mascara. The only thing I don’t like about this mascara is the packaging, but the product itself is pretty good, and it’s quite easy to apply too. It’s a bit wet at first, but not enough to make it clump your lashes, and it works even better when it starts to dry up a bit. I’ve never noticed any smudging, and it lasted all day.

Lengthening: 7/10 Curl: 8/10 Blackness: 10/10 Volume: 10/10 Packaging: 5/10  Wand: 8/10
I’ll start by saying I absolutely love this wand, the added bristles on the end of the brush means that you can get every single individual lash without smudging mascara all over your face, and it’s not very wet at all either, and doesn’t dry up. You can see from the photo the amount of individual bristles that this wand has which makes it amazing! It’s long lasting, with no flaking or smudging.

Lengthening: 9/10 Curl: 10/10 Blackness 10/10 Volume: 8/10 Packaging 10/10 Wand: 10/10 
Okay, I do love the mascara, and omg the packaging is absolutely beautiful but I’v got to be honest, the wand is not my favourite. If I don’t use the supershock to ‘set my lashes’ this one kind of clumps bunches of my lashes together unless I really work hard to avoid that, it’s also pretty wet at first, which makes it worse, but it’s a lot easier to apply once it has started to settle down and dry up a bit. But overall, I do love quite a lot about this mascara, it lasts, doesn’t smudge and I haven’t noticed any flaking, I just wish there was more bristles on the wand.

Lengthening: 8/10 Curl: 9/10 Blackness: 10/10 Volume: 7/10 Packaging 10/10 Wand: 5/10

Rapid Review Benefit

Overall, my favourite has got to be They’re Real!. I love everything about this mascara, and even though the others are amazing, They’re real is definitely the best in my opinion. It lengthens, curls and volumises without smudging or flaking and the extra bristles on the end of the wand are amazing! But as with all makeup products, they do work differently for everyone so,

Which one is your favourite?

Facebook | Twitter | Instagram | Pinterest
Beauty Bloggers Corner 



  1. 09/05/2016 / 5:39 pm

    I’d been thinking of doing this post for ages! My favourite is roller lash as I find they’re real a bit too scratchy and bad gals wand too big! Xx

    • 09/05/2016 / 8:29 pm

      You should! I’d love to know you thoughts on them all
      & so many people prefer the roller lash but I just love big wands haha! I do love the roller lash though, just not as much as they’re real haha xx

  2. 09/05/2016 / 5:51 pm

    This is such a good post idea, lovely photos also! My favourite has to be They’re Real too! xx

  3. 09/05/2016 / 5:55 pm

    Love that post, that makes me want to try They’re Real so much ! 😊

  4. 09/05/2016 / 5:56 pm

    That’s so interesting I actually favour my roller lash the most out of these! Xx

    • 09/05/2016 / 8:31 pm

      So many people do! I do love roller lash but they’re real’s brush is just amazing haha! Xx

          • 09/05/2016 / 8:56 pm

            I think it’s cause my lashes are very weak so there’s not much to improve hah

          • 09/05/2016 / 8:59 pm

            Haha not tooting my own horn but I’m blessed with quite a lot of lashes!
            I know I’m recommending it again, but you should try my beloved SuperShock, it helps set your lashes! Xx

          • 09/05/2016 / 8:59 pm

            You are lucky. I just have really not much to work with hah

          • 09/05/2016 / 9:03 pm

            Have you ever tried any of the tips to growing your lashes? X

          • 09/05/2016 / 9:08 pm

            Yup, I’ve even stuck with one serum for growing them out for maybe a month no but I don’t think anything changed

          • 09/05/2016 / 9:09 pm

            Haha I always wondered wether anything actually works, shame they don’t! X

          • 09/05/2016 / 9:11 pm

            Some people said it did to them, maybe I’m just cursed hah

    • 09/06/2016 / 7:08 am

      Thank you so much haha! I just use a window, but I have quite thin curtains so I pull them close a bit so it’s not too bright & use the colour story app to edit them a bit xxx

  5. 09/06/2016 / 8:14 am

    I have never tried Benefit mascaras before, I think I will have to give it a go 🙂

    • 09/06/2016 / 5:36 pm

      It is isn’t it! Yes you should! Thank you 💕
      Of course xx

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *